The problem of consensus between the state and civil society in Russia: social contradictions and prospects
Research Article
How to Cite
Shevchenko O.M., Shtofer L.L. The problem of consensus between the state and civil society in Russia: social contradictions and prospects. Humanities of the South of Russia. 2023. Vol. 12. No. 1. P. 244-253. DOI: https://doi.org/10.18522/2227-8656.2023.1.19 (in Russ.).
Abstract
Objective of the study is to consider social contradictions and prospects in the development of civil society in Russia.
The methodological basis of the research consists of civilizational and neoinstitutional approaches, as well as the provisions of the theory of civil society.
Research results. This article analyzes social contradictions and prospects for the development of civil society in Russia. For the successful innovative development of the country, both attempts to preserve the paternalistic model of state-society relations and to plant a Western liberal model that is historically alien to Russia are equally unsuitable. The path of Russia is the path of an uneasy dialogue between the government and society in order to achieve their long–term consensus.
Prospects of the study. The problem of relations between the state and civil society is of scientific and practical interest in connection with the need to develop civil institutions in Russia.
Keywords:
civil society, state, monopolization of power, paternalistic type of relations, rule of law, innovative development
References
1. Arato A. (1995) The concept of civil society: ascent, decline and reconstruction – and directions for further research / A. Arato // Polis. Political studies. – No. 3. – Pp. 48-57.
2. Bondar A. V. (2008) On the peculiarities of the study of civil society in Russia / A. V. Bondar, V. A. Dines // Power. – No. 12. – Pp. 1-8.
3. Braudel F. (2014) Grammar of Civilizations / F. Braudel; [translated from French by B. A. Sitnikov]; State lit. the museum. – Moscow: The Whole World. – 551 p. – ISBN 978-5-7777-0642-3.
4. Busygina I. M. (2012) Political Modernization of the state in Russia: necessity, directions, costs, risks / I. M. Busygina, M. M. Fillipov; Liberal Mission Foundation. – Moscow: Liberal Mission Foundation. – 221 p. – ISBN 978-5-903135-33-2 : 800.
5. Weber M. (2003) Political works, 1895-1919 = Gesammelte Politische Schriften, 1895-1919 / M. Weber; [Trans. with him. B. M. Skuratova; Afterword by T. A. Dmitrieva]. – Moscow: Praxis. – 421 p. – ISBN 5-901574-25-7 : 2000.
6. Vlasova S. A. (2009) Cultural and historical context of the formation and formation of civil society in Russia / S. A. Vlasova // Bulletin of Tomsk State University. – No. 323. – Pp. 114-115.
7. Gorshkov M. K. (2013) Civil society and civic consciousness in modern Russia / M. K. Gorshkov // Humanities of the South of Russia. – No. 1. – Pp. 12-22.
8. Gramsci A. (1980) Selected works: [Transl. from it. / A. Gramsci; [Under the general editorship of I. V. Grigorieva et al. – Moscow: Politizdat. – 422 p.
9. Ilyin I. A. (1993) The Path to evidence: / I. A. Ilyin; [Afterword by V. I. Kuraeva; Note by R. K. Medvedeva]. – Moscow: Republic. – 430 p. – ISBN 5-250-01895-5.
10. Makarychev A. S. (2008) Civil society in Russia: between the state and the international community / A. S. Makarychev // Public space, civil society and power. The experience of development and interaction. – Moscow: ROSSPEN. – Pp. 19-30.
11. North D. (1997) Institutes, institutional changes and the functioning of the economy / D. North. – Moscow: Foundation of the Economic Book «Beginnings». – 180 p. – (Modern institutional and evolutionary theory). – ISBN 5-88581-006-0.
12. Ryabev V. V. (2014) Civil society: utopia or reality / V. V. Ryabev // Vestnik MSTU. Proceedings of the Murmansk State Technical University. – Vol. 17. – No. 4. – Pp. 747-752.
13. Struve P. B. (1994) On the measure and limits of liberal conservatism / P. B. Struve // Polis. Political studies. – No. 3. – Pp. 131-134.
14. Toynbee A. J. (1990) Comprehension of History Translated from English / A. J. Toynbee; Comp. A. P. Ogurtsov; Introduction by V. I. Ukolova; Conclusion by E. B. Rashkovsky; [Author's comment by D. E. Kharitonovich, N. I. Kolyshkina]. –Moscow: Progress, B. G. (1990). – 730 p. – ISBN 5-01-001638-0.
15. Toshchenko Zh. T. (2016) Civil society as an object of the sociology of life / Zh. T. Toshchenko // Humanities of the South of Russia. – Vol. 21. – No. 5. – Pp. 50-62.
16. Frank S. L. (1992) Spiritual foundations of society / S. L. Frank; Comp. and auth. introduction by art. P. V. Alekseev. – Moscow: Republic. – 510 p. – ISBN 5-250-01494-1.
17. Hayek F.A. (2012) The Road to Slavery / F. A. Hayek; [transl. from English by M. Gnedovsky]. – Moscow: Astrel: Polygraphizdat. – 317 p. – ISBN 978-5-271-42045-0.
18. Chicherin B. N. (1998) Philosophy of Law / B. N. Chicherin; [Introduction by I. D. Osipova, Pp. 3-18]. – St. Petersburg: Nauka: St. Petersburg Publishing house firm. – 654 p. portr. – ISBN 5-02-026784-8.
19. Spengler O. (1993) The Decline of Europe: Essays on the morphology of world history / O. Spengler; Trans. from German, introductory article and note by K. A. Svasyan. – Moscow: Mysl. – 606 p. – ISBN 5-244-00656-8.
2. Bondar A. V. (2008) On the peculiarities of the study of civil society in Russia / A. V. Bondar, V. A. Dines // Power. – No. 12. – Pp. 1-8.
3. Braudel F. (2014) Grammar of Civilizations / F. Braudel; [translated from French by B. A. Sitnikov]; State lit. the museum. – Moscow: The Whole World. – 551 p. – ISBN 978-5-7777-0642-3.
4. Busygina I. M. (2012) Political Modernization of the state in Russia: necessity, directions, costs, risks / I. M. Busygina, M. M. Fillipov; Liberal Mission Foundation. – Moscow: Liberal Mission Foundation. – 221 p. – ISBN 978-5-903135-33-2 : 800.
5. Weber M. (2003) Political works, 1895-1919 = Gesammelte Politische Schriften, 1895-1919 / M. Weber; [Trans. with him. B. M. Skuratova; Afterword by T. A. Dmitrieva]. – Moscow: Praxis. – 421 p. – ISBN 5-901574-25-7 : 2000.
6. Vlasova S. A. (2009) Cultural and historical context of the formation and formation of civil society in Russia / S. A. Vlasova // Bulletin of Tomsk State University. – No. 323. – Pp. 114-115.
7. Gorshkov M. K. (2013) Civil society and civic consciousness in modern Russia / M. K. Gorshkov // Humanities of the South of Russia. – No. 1. – Pp. 12-22.
8. Gramsci A. (1980) Selected works: [Transl. from it. / A. Gramsci; [Under the general editorship of I. V. Grigorieva et al. – Moscow: Politizdat. – 422 p.
9. Ilyin I. A. (1993) The Path to evidence: / I. A. Ilyin; [Afterword by V. I. Kuraeva; Note by R. K. Medvedeva]. – Moscow: Republic. – 430 p. – ISBN 5-250-01895-5.
10. Makarychev A. S. (2008) Civil society in Russia: between the state and the international community / A. S. Makarychev // Public space, civil society and power. The experience of development and interaction. – Moscow: ROSSPEN. – Pp. 19-30.
11. North D. (1997) Institutes, institutional changes and the functioning of the economy / D. North. – Moscow: Foundation of the Economic Book «Beginnings». – 180 p. – (Modern institutional and evolutionary theory). – ISBN 5-88581-006-0.
12. Ryabev V. V. (2014) Civil society: utopia or reality / V. V. Ryabev // Vestnik MSTU. Proceedings of the Murmansk State Technical University. – Vol. 17. – No. 4. – Pp. 747-752.
13. Struve P. B. (1994) On the measure and limits of liberal conservatism / P. B. Struve // Polis. Political studies. – No. 3. – Pp. 131-134.
14. Toynbee A. J. (1990) Comprehension of History Translated from English / A. J. Toynbee; Comp. A. P. Ogurtsov; Introduction by V. I. Ukolova; Conclusion by E. B. Rashkovsky; [Author's comment by D. E. Kharitonovich, N. I. Kolyshkina]. –Moscow: Progress, B. G. (1990). – 730 p. – ISBN 5-01-001638-0.
15. Toshchenko Zh. T. (2016) Civil society as an object of the sociology of life / Zh. T. Toshchenko // Humanities of the South of Russia. – Vol. 21. – No. 5. – Pp. 50-62.
16. Frank S. L. (1992) Spiritual foundations of society / S. L. Frank; Comp. and auth. introduction by art. P. V. Alekseev. – Moscow: Republic. – 510 p. – ISBN 5-250-01494-1.
17. Hayek F.A. (2012) The Road to Slavery / F. A. Hayek; [transl. from English by M. Gnedovsky]. – Moscow: Astrel: Polygraphizdat. – 317 p. – ISBN 978-5-271-42045-0.
18. Chicherin B. N. (1998) Philosophy of Law / B. N. Chicherin; [Introduction by I. D. Osipova, Pp. 3-18]. – St. Petersburg: Nauka: St. Petersburg Publishing house firm. – 654 p. portr. – ISBN 5-02-026784-8.
19. Spengler O. (1993) The Decline of Europe: Essays on the morphology of world history / O. Spengler; Trans. from German, introductory article and note by K. A. Svasyan. – Moscow: Mysl. – 606 p. – ISBN 5-244-00656-8.
Article
Received: 20.12.2022
Accepted: 18.02.2023
Citation Formats
Other cite formats:
APA
Shevchenko, O. M., & Shtofer, L. L. (2023). The problem of consensus between the state and civil society in Russia: social contradictions and prospects. Humanities of the South of Russia, 12(1), 244-253. https://doi.org/10.18522/2227-8656.2023.1.19
Section
CULTURE AND GLOBALIZATION
