Transforming the conditions of medical practitioners’ professional activities in the process of the healthcare service optimization

  • Liudmila S. Shilova Institute of Sociology of FCTAS RAS Liudmila-shilova@yandex.ru
How to Cite
Shilova L.S. 2019. Transforming the conditions of medical practitioners’ professional activities in the process of the healthcare service optimization — Sociologicheskaja nauka i social’naja praktika. Vol. 7. No. 2. P. 117-131. DOI: https://doi.org/10.19181/snsp.2019.7.2.6413

Abstract

Today, medical administration assesses any practitioner’s performance efficiency based on the revenue they bring to the medical establishment. The consequences of the substitution of such traditional concepts as “patient”, “doctor” and “medical care” pursuant to the market approach to the medical function by “client”, “service provider” and “medical services” have been fully revealed. Following market paradigm, meaning that the “customer is always right”, patients have become more demanding of practitioners’ work. Medical practitioners under the conditions of overloading and overscheduling, strict regulations of the relationship with the medical establishment authority and insurance companies make mistakes more often. The main instrument for evaluating medical activities is multilayered legal documents, generated by various medical management entities and poorly coordinated with each other. Meanwhile, control practice follows its own rules and laws, and the complexity of the instrument makes no obstacle for the inspectors. Among insurers and officials there has developed a strong conviction in the physicians’ guilt, and that they a priori deserve criminal sentence. This conviction has been replicated by the media (for which such sort of materials helps to raise ratings according to the laws of the yellow press), and it has become shared by society, in particular, by patients. The number of patients’ complaints to the Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation has been increasing rapidly. In response to the “patients’ terrorism” practitioners have adopted a strategy of “protective medicine”, minimizing the risks of treatment to the detriment of its effectiveness. The established practice of doctor-patient relationship is equally harmful to both of them. Traditional professional medical values have turned out to be in conflict with the new requirements of the medical institution authorities caused by the commercialization of the medical care. Although most practitioners have the strength to overcome the crisis of workplace values due to the humanistic component of their profession, their medical activity is accompanied by dissatisfaction and burnout. Healthcare service optimization has resulted in strained relations between patients and healthcare providers.
Keywords:
commercialization, market mentality, “patient terrorism”, professional values, burnout

Author Biography

Liudmila S. Shilova, Institute of Sociology of FCTAS RAS
Institute of Sociology of FCTAS RAS

References

Agadzhanyan E. G. Chem zakonchitsya vojna s vrachami v blizhajshee vremya. [How will the war with doctors end in the near future]. [Electronniy resurs]. YandeksDzen: [web site] https://zen.yandex. ru/media/stom/chem-zakonchitsia-voina-s-vrachami-v-blijaishee-vremia-5c2b99b2561f7a00aa62b005 (data obraschenija: 31.01.2019). (In Russ.).



Βelyj M, Fedorov L. Shtrafy zastavyat medikov massovo ukhodit’ iz professii. [Consumer extremism leads to the refusal of doctors from new methods of treatment]. [Electronniy resurs]. Medvestnik. Portal of the Russian doctor. URL: https://medvestnik.ru/content/news/Potrebitelskii-terrorizmprivodit-k-otkazu-vrachei-ot-novyh-metodov-lecheniya.html (data obraschenija: 31.01.2019). (In Russ.).



Beskaravaynay T. Potrebitel’skij ekstremizm privodit k otkazu vrachej ot novykh metodov lecheniya. [Consumer extremism leads to the refusal of doctors from new treatments]. [Electronniy resurs]. Medvestnik. Portal of the Russian doctor. URL: https://medvestnik.ru/content/news/Potrebitelskiiterrorizm-privodit-k-otkazu-vrachei-ot-novyh-metodov-lecheniya.html (data obraschenija: 20.01.2019). (In Russ.).



Beskaravaynay T. Advokat: pri dejstvuyuschem zakonodatel’stve u vrachej prosto svyazany ruki. [Lawyer: under the current legislation, doctors simply have their hands tied]. [Electronniy resurs]. Medvestnik. Portal of the Russian doctor. URL: https://medvestnik.ru/content/news/Advokat-prideistvuushem-zakonodatelstve-u-vrachei-prosto-svyazany-ruki.html (data obraschenija: 04.18.2019). (In Russ.).



Federal’nyj Zakon «Ob osnovakh okhrany zdorov’ya grazhdan v Rossijskoj Federatsii» ot 21.11.2011 № 323-FZ. [Federal Law “On the Basics of the Protection of Citizens’ Health in the Russian Federation” of 21.11.2011 No. 323-FZ]. [Electronniy resurs]. ConsultantPlus: [web site] URL: http:// www.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc;base=MED;n=44531#03181604411636966 (data obraschenija: 02.10.2019). (In Russ.).



Halfin R. A. Rukovodit’ meditsinskoj organizatsiej dolzhen vrach. [The medical organization should be managed by a doctor]. [Electronniy resurs]. Doctors of the Russian Federation: [web site] URL: https://vrachirf.ru/concilium/58590.html?utm_source=vrch&utm_medium=dstr_22&utm_campaign=msg_5212 (data obraschenija: 19.04.2019). (In Russ.).



Inogda vrachi prosto ne imeyut prava pomogat’. [Sometimes doctors simply do not have the right to help]. Magazine “Spark” № 42. 11.05.2018. (In Russ.).



Kak projti cherez «koshmar patsientskogo ekstremizma». [How to get through the “nightmare of patient extremism”. Materials of the round table organized by “Doctor Peter”]. [Electronniy resurs]. Doctors of the Russian Federation: [web site]. URL: https://vrachirf.ru/concilium/59219.html?utm_ source=vrch&utm_medium=dstr_22&utm_campaign=msg_5327 (data obraschenija: 03.05.2019). (In Russ.).



Kolichestvo ugolovnykh del protiv vrachej za god vyroslo na 24%. [The number of criminal cases against doctors for the year increased by 24%]. [Electronniy resurs]. Doctors of the Russian Federation: [website] URL: https://vrachirf.ru/company-announce-single/57988?utm_source=vrch&utm_ medium=dstr_22&utm_campaign=msg_5081 (data obraschenija: 03.04.2019). (In Russ.).



Nazarenko G. B. Vrachevanie – ne sfera uslug. [Vrachevanie is not a sphere of services]. [Electronniy resurs]. Doctors of the Russian Federation: [web site]. URL: //https://vrachirf.ru/concilium/54775.html (data obraschenija: 01.20.2019). (In Russ.).



Nikolaev B. Reforma rossijskogo zdravookhraneniya i tsennostnye konflikty professionalizma. [The reform of the Russian public health and value conflicts of professionalism]. Journal of Social Policy Studies. 2015. № 4. Т. 13. P. 611–626. (In Russ.).



Opros «Vrachebnye oshibki» i vvedenie ugolovnogo nakazaniya za ikh sovershenie. [The survey “Medical errors” and the introduction of criminal penalties for their commission]. [Electronniy resurs]. Doctors of the Russian Federation: [web site]. URL: https://vrachirf.ru/companyannouncesingle/57822?utm_source=vrch&utm_medium=dstr_22&utm_campaign=msg_5086 (data obraschenija: 06.04.2019). (In Russ.).



Patsient ili klient? K chemu vedut meditsinu potrebitel’skie zakony. [Patient or client? What do consumer medicine laws lead to]. [Electronniy resurs]. FIF.RU: [web site]. URL: http://www.aif.ru/ society/healthcare/pacient_ili_klient_k_chemu_vedut_medicinu_potrebitelskie_zakony (data obraschenija: 03.07.2017). (In Russ.).



Rabota vracha segodnya – eto chjornaya lotereya. [The work of the doctor today is the black lottery]. [Electronniy resurs]. Doctors of the Russian Federation: [web site]. URL: https://vrachirf.ru/ concilium/58040.html?utm_source=vrch&utm_medium=dstr_22&utm_campaign=msg_5086 (data obraschenija: 04.06.2019). (In Russ.).



Regulirovat’ deyatel’nost’ vracha Ugolovnym kodeksom – eto nonsense. [Regulating the activities of a doctor with the criminal code is nonsense]. [Electronniy resurs]. MED RUSSIA: [website]. URL: https://medrussia.org/28008-deyatelnost-vracha/ (data obraschenija: 03.04 2019). (In Russ.).



Reznik I. Medikov kidayut na den’gi. [Medics throw on the money]. [Electronniy resurs]. MED RUSSIA: [web site]. URL: https://medrussia.org/2228-medikov-kidayut-na-dengi/ (data obraschenija: 03.12.2017). (In Russ.).



Slozhnosti vzaimoponimaniya. Kak dostich’ soglasiya patsientam i vracham? [Difficulties of mutual understanding. How to reach agreement between patients and doctors?]. [Electronniy resurs]. Doctors of the Russian Federation: [web site]. URL: https://vrachirf.ru/concilium/59157.html?utm_ source=vrch&utm_medium=dstr_22&utm_campaign=msg_5326 (data obraschenija: 04.30.2019). (In Russ.).



Shtrafy zastavyat medikov massovo ukhodit’ iz professii. [Penalties will force physicians to leave the profession en masse]. [Electronniy resurs] // URA.RU: [web-site]. URL: https://ura.news/articles/1036277674?fbclid=IwAR16_JULSs6toA0CDKuzYxAMFuuzYE2xL1iWILMAym_gNP9I4TsiILGkLmU (data obraschenija: 09.03.2019). (In Russ.).



V Rossii net ponimaniya togo, chto takoe kachestvo meditsinskoj pomoschi. [There is no understanding in Russia of what medical care quality is]. [Electronniy resurs]. MED RUSSIA: [web site]. URL: https://medrussia.org/27135-net-ponimaniya/?fbclid=IwAR0JNM7MLqE58gOaGYEgDO2vO6It15oTsJGkUmYYSln4ueFxlTq9Vp6xi1Q (data obraschenija: 08.03.2019). (In Russ.).



«Zhaloby na vrachej merkantil’ny»: Patsient ne khochet, chtoby vrach sidel v tyur’me, on khochet poluchit’ den’gi. [Complaints against doctors mercantile. The patient does not want the doctor to be in prison, he wants to get the money]. [Electronniy resurs]. MED RUSSIA: [web site]. URL: https:// medrussia.org/28557-zhalobi-na-vrachey/ (data obraschenija: 04.19.2019). (In Russ.).



Zvezdina P. Pochti 25% rossijskikh vrachej poluchali ukazaniya navyazyvat’ platnye uslugi. [Nearly 25% of Russian doctors were instructed to impose paid services]. RBC. [Electronniy resurs]. URL: https://www.rbc.ru/society/10/12/2018/5c09419b9a7947781ad3fa28?fbclid=IwAR0X4FfALEL1bhbF RKX-cBgTxAM7vjMLTF06LqwnZIfhJZlZ0QpHSueXP4U (data obraschenija: 10.12.2018). (In Russ.).
Citation Formats
Other cite formats:

Harvard
Shilova, L. S. (2019) ’Transforming the conditions of medical practitioners’ professional activities in the process of the healthcare service optimization’, Sociologicheskaja nauka i social’naja praktika, 7(2), pp. 117-131. doi: https://doi.org/10.19181/snsp.2019.7.2.6413.